Taking my liberties to write on anything relating to black
culture, I’d like to take a minute to comment on Beyoncé’s new video and song
release “Formation.” After one of Rhodes College’s most renowned and
controversial professors wrote an article for Rolling Stone (http://www.rollingstone.com/music/features/beyonces-black-southern-formation-20160208)
on the topic, I cannot help to comment on its relevance and necessity. Beyoncé
uses her popularity to turn a new page in her career going from a “Love on Top”
mindset to one that’s politically and socially relevant with “Formation.” She
uses her southern black woman identity to make a statement and possibly one of
the most watched nights and music events annually at the 50th
Superbowl. In reading Dr. Robinson’s article in Rolling Stone, I also decided
to read the comments addressing the article in some problematic ways with some
saying “the only way we make things racial is when we bring up race.” Obviously
this person missed the big picture.
It is rare that someone of her stature and popularity takes
a stance politically for fear of losing fans and good favor with her audience.
It is apparent that Beyoncé doesn’t care and is instead choosing to risk all of
that to make people listen. She chooses to address intersectionality, black
queerness, womanhood, violence, police brutality, and the south in less than
four minutes. All issues of absolute relevance at this point in our nation’s
history, she continues and even highlights this conversation.
During this music video she points out major problems people
of color face in our nation. The fear of violence and death because of the
lackluster care police officers take in their jobs. The contrast between having
too much money and having no money at all forced to live in the projects. The
idea that because you’re poor, you have no option to leave New Orleans before,
during, or after Katrina because of the way our nation handles poverty stricken
people in poverty stricken neighborhoods which are majority people of color. In
particular she makes a statement for women and the power they should strive for
without regard for the power of men. She calls herself an innovator in comparing
herself to Bill Gates and in that moment calls for a formation of women to come
together for the solidarity of black feminism, something often overlooked and
hardly talked about.
Beyoncé is fighting this battle of structural racism and
white privilege. She addresses major issues of how structural racism has
affected black people and how she saw it in her hometown of Houston, Texas. She
tackles white privilege by having practically no white people appear in her
video. This flips the script on the majority white media that exists in America’s
pop culture. She’s making black women the main character of the stories she
believes need to be told. What is so important about this is that Beyonce is an artist that has access to nearly every audiences and especially the ones that need to be targeted: white and black listeners. She uses this access to create a message that needs to be heard, assessed, debated, and implemented.
I think that it is so important for those who have the attention of many, to use that to take a stand for what she/he may believe in, to speak out for those who are not publicly known. A former New York Mayor says, "I thought it was really outrageous that she used it (the halftime show) as a platform to attack police officers who are the people who protect her and protect us and keep us alive." Others mention that Americans should have the right to "wholesome entertainment" without political statements, etc. To this, I must comment on the fact that the same people who are shaming Beyonce for using her status to make political statements, are also using their own status to speak against her. Finally, one must analyze and question the reasons why others are feeling so threatened and enraged by her statement.
ReplyDeleteWhile I was scrolling through Facebook, I came across an Odyssey article by Nico Tavella titled, “Beyoncé Is Not Here For Your White Sorority Culture, And Neither Am I.” The article was published on Feburary 9th, 2016 and while it starts out praising Beyoncé for “essentially [constructing] a compilation of Black culture and Black history into a single video” it ends with a critique on “white feminism.” Tavella shared that when he was sitting in Starbucks, four white girls, who are members of a sorority that is supposedly progressive and promotes women empowerment, were dismissing Beyoncé’s video because they could not identify with and it made them feel left out. The “Formation” video features black queerness, beautiful black hairstyles, the Creole culture in Louisiana, the aftermath of Hurricane Katrina, and unity among black women. According to Tavella the music video was about the Black community; therefore, the four girls were supposed to feel left out. As Tavella listened to their conversation, he was disheartened because Greek-life college sororities are majority white; therefore, the brand of “feminism” these girls prefer is against equality and justice for all women of different races. White sorority feminism has privilege, yet is not enough when it comes to fighting for true feminism because like Tavella wrote; “feminism is intersectional, it intersects with race and sexuality.” I found this article to be very interesting because not only am I a white female, I am also a member of a sorority. I think my exploration with Africana Studies allowed me to fully appreciate the “Formation” video because I understood the approach towards black female empowerment and the progression of history Beyoncé preformed.
ReplyDeleteHere is the link to the article http://theodysseyonline.com/uni-rochester/albino-alligators/308193
This comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteAs both Ashley and Alexa mention, Beyoncé uses her social status as a well known celebrity as a way to spread her message. By creating a music video, and designing a Superbowl performance that both embody the message she is trying to convey, Beyoncé is reaching out to a wider audience, thus allowing her message to be made known to those who might not listen to or buy her music.
ReplyDeleteBeyoncé's 'Formation' is a rallying cry to women everywhere, especially those who are members of the Black community, to wake up and stand together, to support one another, and to not accept the way that society is treating them.
By singing about issues of great importance, such as racism, sexism and class discrimination, Beyoncé is raising awareness about these issues, which in doing so, re-opens a dialogue about the intersectionality of race, sex and class; a conversation that desperately needs to be had.
The scene at the end of “Formation,” where Beyoncé gracefully sinks into the water on top of a police car, was one that caught my eye for being quite visually stunning. I know that in the song Beyoncé is attempting to cover a lot of issues that African-Americans are facing and she has to do so in the very short time frame of a music video. The inclusion of a lot of Hurricane Katrina imagery is one that I have seen that is drawing a lot of controversy from people of all races who were in New Orleans during the hurricane or had loved ones who died. I saw an article online where one man was particularly offended by the sinking car scene. He asks: Do you think that the women in New Orleans had a full face of makeup and were gracefully descending into the… water when Hurricane Katrina happened and the government was nowhere to be found to rescue them?” I just found it noteworthy that people of all races are finding the Katrina imagery in Beyoncé’s video especially troubling. They condemn Beyoncé for profiting off an event that she was not really affected by. Hurricane Katrina was a singular event, unlike the ongoing struggle that African-Americans face against things like police brutality.
ReplyDeletehttp://www.vibe.com/2016/02/beyonce-formation-hurricane-katrina/
I think you summed it up best with, "It is apparent that Beyoncé doesn’t care and is instead choosing to risk all of that to make people listen. She chooses to address intersectionality, black queerness, womanhood, violence, police brutality, and the south in less than four minutes." I agree with this assumption. With racial tensions escalating and becoming a more applicable issue in society, African American role models are aiding this change. Beyonce is already well-established, her music is renowned, so why should she address prominent issues? She is influential. People listen to her, especially the younger generations. She serves as a voice to call out gender discrimination and police brutality; what better way to influence people than to have Americans singing her lyrics? In this regard, it is similar to Kendrick Lamar and arguably Kanye. Beyonce 's stance is appealing to me because it offers a sense of inclusion into mainstream American life, this inclusion involves the acceptance of all races and equal opportunity, no matter what gender or race you may be. This is a step in the right direction.
ReplyDelete