A few months ago, one of my friends asked me whether or not I
believed that white privilege was still a thing in the U.S. I told him that I
did, and he asked me for an example. After thinking about it for a little bit, I
decided to address the inequality in schools, as it encompassed so much more
and was an excellent example of subtle white privilege. I began with a
statistic that I had read about for my psychology class last semester. It was a
statistic that had been drawn from a study that had inspected differences in
black and white student’s standardized testing achievements. It began by
inspecting the two groups’ scores in Kindergarten, which found the achievements
to be comparable to one another. Then, the study inspected these same children’s
scores when they were in 3rd grade. Three years of elementary school
later, the white students had scored appreciably higher than the black
students. This study showed two important things: (1) that black and white
students intellectually began at about the same level, and (2) that by 3rd
grade, white students had made significant gains over black students.
After setting this as the basis for my discussion, I inspected
why this difference occurred. As it turns out, the white students came from a
wealthier area than the black students. And since property taxes pay for
schools, this meant that the white school had significantly more funding than
the black school. This higher funding meant more teachers, newer textbooks and
more technology. This also meant that parents of the white students were more
likely to have more time to spend with their children as they would not have to
work longer hours and deal with as much stress with regard to finances. I’m not
trying to claim that all predominantly black schools are poor, but rather that
a disproportionate number of black schools are less wealthy than their white
counterparts. For example, in Memphis alone the graduation rates in the poorer
neighborhoods are significantly lower than they are in the more wealthy ones. These
poorer neighborhoods also happen to be predominantly black while the wealthier ones
are not. Across the country, white graduation rates are decently higher than
black graduation rates. This was enough to convince my friend that white
privilege was in fact still prevalent in the U.S.
After establishing this, we began to discuss affirmative action
in colleges and universities. After seeing this unfair racial education gap, it
becomes clear why we have affirmative action, if we did not, minority higher education
rates would be even more abysmal than they are now. We began to discuss the goals
of affirmative action next. I referenced a few studies that showed the impact
that parental education played on the education level of their offspring. The main
result being that children who had parents who attended and finished college
were much more likely to do the same than children whose parents did not do
these things. I was glad to have this discussion with my friend, and I’m glad
that my classes have helped me to better understand the contemporary moment.
http://everydaylife.globalpost.com/education-level-parent-affect-childs-achievement-school-6869
Brian, I really admire that you were able to have this conversation with your friend. There are several areas in my hometown that are direct examples of the disparity between public funding for schools. The neighborhood where I grew up had very high property taxes to fund our school. We had several opportunities to volunteer in lower achieving schools. Something to be mentioned is that Dallas is so segregated that the lower achieving schools were usually made up of areas that housed minority students. It is something that I still do not understand or accept but I know that students there are able to use affirmative action to help them follow their dreams. Maybe one day, if more conversations like yours happen, communities can come together to support everyone, not just the majority, in following their dreams.
ReplyDelete